Important Disclaimer: This calculator provides educational estimates only and should not be considered financial, tax, or legal advice. Actual results may vary significantly based on investment performance, tax law changes, and individual circumstances. Charitable remainder trusts involve complex regulations, and the 10% remainder rule and other IRS requirements must be met for tax benefits. You should consult with qualified financial, tax, and legal professionals before making any decisions about establishing a charitable remainder trust. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
Introduction
Charitable remainder trusts can be powerful wealth transfer tools, but the math behind them isn't exactly straightforward. Whether you're considering a charitable remainder annuity trust or a charitable remainder unitrust, understanding the numbers upfront can help you make smarter decisions about your estate planning strategy.
Whether you're considering a charitable remainder annuity trust or a charitable remainder unitrust, this guide breaks down the numbers you actually need to know - without requiring a math degree or five cups of coffee.
New to AdvisorFinder? Welcome! Our mission is to help people make more informed financial decisions. Once you're finished with this calculator, you might want to subscribe to our newsletter.
Using the calculator (and what to do with the results)
The calculator on this page helps you model different scenarios, but remember: it's giving you projections based on assumptions about investment returns, your longevity, and future tax rates.
Reality will be different. Use the calculator to understand the general magnitude of benefits and compare different options, not to make precise predictions about your financial future.
Most importantly, if the calculator shows that a CRT could make sense for your situation, don't try to implement this strategy yourself. The legal and tax requirements are complex enough that even small mistakes can disqualify the entire trust.
When you're ready to explore charitable remainder trust options, you can find financial advisors who specialize in estate planning and charitable giving strategies. Use our assessment to connect with professionals who actually understand the math behind CRTs and can help you determine whether this approach aligns with your financial goals.
How These Calculations can Change Your Decision-Making
Running the numbers and understanding the math helps you avoid the three biggest CRT mistakes people seem to make.
Mistake #1: Choosing the wrong trust type for your situation
Emma was 62 and terrified of inflation eating away at her retirement income. Her advisor recommended a CRAT because "the payments are more predictable."
Bad advice. At 62, Emma had potentially 30+ years of retirement ahead of her. A fixed payment that looked adequate today would be worth significantly less in purchasing power by the time she was 85.
She switched to a CRUT and slept better knowing her payments would adjust upward with market performance and inflation.
The lesson: Use the calculator to model both options over your expected lifespan, not just the first few years.
Mistake #2: Ignoring the investment strategy inside the trust
Michael contributed $1.5 million to a CRT and then invested the trust assets in conservative bonds yielding 3%. His 6% annual payout meant the trust was paying out twice what it was earning.
The math was guaranteed to fail. Within 15 years, the trust would be depleted, the charity would get nothing, and Michael would have given up $1.5 million for a series of payments that could have been replicated with a simple annuity.
The lesson: Your payout rate and investment strategy must align, or the whole thing falls apart.
Mistake #3: Assuming this strategy works for everyone with appreciated assets
Sarah had $800,000 in highly appreciated stock and got excited about the tax benefits of a CRT. The problem? She needed that money for her retirement, not as a charitable gift.
After running the numbers, she realized she'd be better off selling the stock, paying the taxes, and investing the proceeds in a diversified portfolio. The CRT would have reduced her overall wealth in exchange for a tax deduction on a charitable gift she couldn't really afford.
The lesson: CRTs work best when you genuinely want to make a substantial charitable gift and can afford to give up control of the assets permanently.
How Charitable Remainder Trusts Work
1. Transfer Assets - You contribute appreciated assets (stocks, real estate, cash) to an irrevocable trust
2. Receive Income - The trust pays you or your beneficiaries annual income for a specified term or lifetime
3. Enjoy Tax Benefits - Receive an immediate charitable tax deduction and potentially avoid capital gains taxes
4. Support Charity - At the end of the trust term, remaining assets go to your chosen qualified charity
The trust is professionally managed and invested to potentially grow over time, providing you with income while supporting causes you care about. Your annual payments can be fixed (CRAT) or variable based on trust performance (CRUT).
Working With an Advisor Who Understands CRTs
Here's an uncomfortable truth: Most financial advisors understand the concept of charitable remainder trusts but many have never actually implemented one.
You want someone who's done this before, not someone who might be learning with your million-dollar contribution.
Questions that help you determine if your advisor is truly a CRT experts:
- "How many CRTs have you established in the past two years?"
- "What's your typical investment strategy inside the trust?"
- "How do you coordinate this with estate planning and insurance strategies?"
- "Can you explain how the Section 7520 rate affects my deduction?"
If they can't give specific, detailed answers, you may want to keep looking.
The same applies to estate planning attorneys. Drafting a CRT requires specialized knowledge of IRS regulations that many generalist attorneys don't have. Ask about their specific experience with charitable remainder trusts, not just their general estate planning credentials.
Here's our full guide on questions to ask an advisor before hiring them
Which Calculations Matter for Charitable Remainder Trusts?
Here's the thing about CRT calculations: there are dozens of formulas floating around, but only five numbers really determine whether this strategy makes sense for your situation.
Everything else is just noise designed to make tax attorneys feel important.
1. Your annual payout (the money you'll actually see)
This is the number that pays your bills. Everything else is academic if this doesn't work for your lifestyle.
For CRATs (the predictable choice): Your payment stays the same every year, no matter what happens in the market. Take your initial contribution, multiply by your chosen percentage, and that's your annual check. Forever.
Example: $1,000,000 contribution × 6% = $60,000 every year until you die.
Market crashes? Still $60,000. Bull market? Still $60,000. Zombie apocalypse? Still $60,000 (assuming the banks survive).
For CRUTs (the inflation fighter): Your payment adjusts every year based on how the trust investments perform. Good years mean bigger checks. Bad years mean smaller ones.
Same $1,000,000 contribution with 6% payout rate:
- Year 1: $60,000 (based on $1M initial value)
- Year 2: Maybe $66,000 (if assets grew to $1.1M)
- Year 3: Maybe $54,000 (if market tanked and assets dropped to $900K)
Most people under 65 choose CRUTs for inflation protection. Most people over 70 choose CRATs for predictability. There's your rule of thumb.
The calculator on this page lets you play with both scenarios to see which feels right for your situation.
2. Your charitable deduction (the immediate tax gift)
This is where the IRS gives you money upfront for promising to give money to charity later. It's like a tax discount for being generous with your future self's assets.
The basic math: Take your contribution amount, subtract the present value of all the payments you'll receive over your lifetime, and what's left is your charitable deduction.
Reality check: You won't get a deduction equal to your full contribution. The IRS isn't stupid. If you contribute $1,000,000 but expect to receive $650,000 in lifetime payments, your deduction is roughly $350,000.
But here's what nobody tells you: you might not be able to use that entire deduction in year one. The IRS limits charitable deductions to 50% of your adjusted gross income. Make $200,000? Your deduction is capped at $100,000 per year, with five years to use the rest.
This is why the timing of your CRT matters enormously. Do it in a high-income year for maximum immediate benefit.
3. Tax deferral on your asset sale (the real magic)
Here's where charitable remainder trusts get interesting. When you contribute appreciated assets, the trust can sell them without paying capital gains tax immediately. You pay the tax gradually as you receive distributions.
Back to David's Apple stock situation:
- Direct sale: $2,300,000 - $400,000 taxes = $1,900,000 to invest
- CRT contribution: Full $2,300,000 working inside the trust
That extra $400,000 earning returns can make a massive difference over 20+ years of distributions. The trust essentially gives you an interest-free loan on your capital gains taxes.
The catch? You're still paying those taxes eventually, just spread out over your lifetime. If tax rates go up dramatically in the future, this strategy could backfire. But most people bet on their tax rates being lower in retirement.
4. What's left for charity (and why it matters for your planning)
The remainder calculation tells you how much will eventually go to your chosen charity. This isn't just feel-good math - it affects your other estate planning decisions.
For CRATs, if you live longer than expected and the trust earns decent returns, the charity could receive substantially more than the projected remainder. Live shorter than expected with poor returns, and the charity might get very little.
For CRUTs, the remainder is more predictable as a percentage of assets, since your payments adjust with performance.
Why this matters: Many people use life insurance to "replace" the assets going to charity, ensuring their heirs inherit something while they capture the tax benefits. Understanding the likely remainder value helps you determine how much insurance to buy.
5. Income replacement analysis (the reality check)
This is where you compare the CRT strategy to just keeping your assets and managing them yourself.
The honest calculation includes:
- What your assets might generate in investment income (after taxes)
- Estate taxes your heirs would pay on inherited assets
- The value of your immediate charitable deduction
- The benefit of deferring capital gains taxes
Most people skip this step and just focus on the tax benefits. That's a mistake. If keeping your assets and paying the taxes upfront gives your family a better financial outcome, the CRT doesn't make sense no matter how clever it sounds.
The calculator on this page includes an income replacement comparison so you can see the real numbers side by side.
Charitable Remainder Trust Calculator FAQ
What's the difference between a CRAT and CRUT?
Here's the thing: CRATs pay you the same amount every year, no matter what. CRUTs adjust your payment based on how the investments perform.
Think of it like this: CRAT is like a pension - predictable but potentially eroded by inflation. CRUT is like owning stocks - your income goes up and down with performance, but you get inflation protection when things go well.
Most people under 65 choose CRUTs. Most people over 70 choose CRATs. There's your rule of thumb.
How much can I actually deduct on my taxes?
The IRS requires that at least 10% of your contribution will eventually go to charity. Most people get deductions between 20-50% of their contribution amount, depending on their age and the payout rate they choose.
But here's what nobody tells you: you might not be able to use the entire deduction in year one. The IRS limits charitable deductions to 50% of your adjusted gross income, with a five-year carryforward for the rest.
Run the numbers with your tax professional before you commit.
What happens if the investments perform terribly?
With a CRAT, you keep getting paid the same amount even if the trust loses money. Eventually, the trust could run out of assets, which means smaller (or zero) remainder for charity, but your payments continue until that happens.
With a CRUT, your payments shrink if investments perform poorly. But the trust can't completely run dry because your payments adjust downward with the asset values.
Neither scenario is ideal, which is why the investment strategy matters enormously.
Can I change my mind after setting this up?
Short answer: No. Charitable remainder trusts are irrevocable.
Once you sign those papers, the assets belong to the trust forever. You can't take them back, change the charity, or modify the payout rate. This isn't a decision you make lightly at 11pm after reading a blog post.
Some people get around this by naming a donor-advised fund as the charitable beneficiary, which gives them flexibility in directing the eventual charitable gifts.
What if I live longer than expected?
You know that worry about outliving your money? CRTs actually provide some protection here.
With both types of trusts, you receive payments for life, no matter how long you live. If you're 70 and live to 95, you still get your annual payment in year 25.
The trade-off is that a longer-than-expected life means less money eventually goes to charity, but that's their problem, not yours.
How do I know if my advisor actually understands these trusts?
Ask them to explain the Section 7520 rate and how it affects your deduction calculation. If they look confused, find someone else.
Most financial advisors understand the concept of CRTs but have never actually implemented one. You want someone who's done this before, not someone learning alongside you with your million-dollar contribution.
Also ask about the investment strategy inside the trust. Many advisors focus on the tax benefits but forget that poor investment returns can ruin the whole strategy.
Should I use appreciated stock or cash for the contribution?
Almost always appreciated stock or other assets with large gains. That's where the tax magic happens.
Contributing cash to a CRT is like using a Ferrari to drive to the corner store - you're not getting the full benefit. The tax deferral on capital gains is often the biggest financial advantage of the entire strategy.
If you only have cash to contribute, there might be simpler charitable strategies that make more sense.
What's this about using life insurance to "replace" the assets?
Some people buy life insurance equal to the amount they're contributing to the CRT. When they die, their heirs get the insurance payout, and the charity gets the trust remainder.
It's like having your cake and eating it too - you get the lifetime income stream, the tax benefits, and your kids still inherit something.
But life insurance isn't free, and it might not make sense if you're already older or have health issues. Run the numbers carefully before assuming this strategy works for your situation.